Nine letters between the Reid and Simpson familiesWritten between 1816 and 1847 Contributed and transcribed by Ralph Simpson
The following letters are copyrighted by the University of North Carolina and posted here with their permission.
They were given to the University as a gift from Miss Cora F. Sanders, 19F Springvale
Apartments, Croton-on-Hudson, New York, 10520 in March 1969. The donor's
mother was a Reid from Tulip, Arkansas. She writes:
In the 1840s and 1850s, the Reids
and the Simpsons, who had been tobacco planters in eastern North Carolina,
migrated to Arkansas where they became cotton planters. This 1847 letter
[below] was addressed to Keziah Reid in Tulip, Arkansas where she was staying
either with her daughter Clarissa Smith or her sister Mollie Simpson Harris
(Mrs. Tyre Harris). In 1855, Thomas J. Reid (my grandfather) youngest son
of Major John Reid, went from his tobacco plantation in Person County, North
Carolina to Arkansas. The women and children of the family made the
long journey in carriages, the men were on horseback, and the slaves were in
covered wagons.
All these families built their
homes in Tulip, Arkansas. Their cotton plantations were on the Mississippi
where their cotton could be shipped to New Orleans. Up to the time of the
Civil War, they were all very prosperous. They brought a teacher from Boston
to teach their children, sent the older ones to Eastern schools. They had
fine homes. My mother (daughter of Thomas Reid) said their home had iron
gates, a long, tree-lined drive to the house, which was white Southern Colonial
with a two-story veranda. Her father had about 270 slaves; his uncle-in-law,
Tyre Harris, had over 1,000 slaves.
In the last paragraph of this
October 1847 letter Duke Simpson writes: "You request to know of my father your
age and his. You were born on the 8th February 1767 and he was
born on the 3rd of March 1770." Note the penciled figures at
the end of this letter. Evidently Keziah figured her age, several
times. The last time at age 88, she died at age 91.
From the John Reid Papers #3882
Southern Historical Collection, Wilson Library
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
1) John B. Reid to his father, Major John Reid (1/9/1816)
Richmond Ky. Janr. 9th 1816
Dear Father,
No doubt when you open this letter & see the early date of it from the one I sent you by Col.
Murphy, you will be a little astonished, the more so when you see it is from Richmond. After my
compliments to you, mother & the rest of the family, I will state to you
the cause of my living in this place. When Col. Murphy started home I
rode with him to this place & when we had parted & I was about to start
back to uncle Maj. Grugett, the gentleman with whom I board, understanding that
it was my intention to go to school in this country somewhere, informed me that
there was a gentleman lately arrived here from Boston who was well qualified to
teach & wished to get a small private school in his home, I told him I
could give no answer untill I saw uncle & conversed with him on the subject
as I intended to be entirely guided by him - consequently next day uncle and myself
went to town to take my deposition which was done accordingly. & then
Maj. Grugett introduced uncle to the gentleman when after considerable
conversation with him & his being so highly recommended by an acquaintance
of uncles' he concluded to send me to him awhile - so I commenced on the 19th
Dec in order that if I should not like his teaching I might leave off going
& loose less time than I would if I should have commenced after Christmas -
but in the time that I went I liked him very well as a teacher & determined
to continue with him - but next it was necessary to know what he would have for
tuition, which he said would be one dollar per week - which I immediately
determined not to give him - but after consulting with uncle - he thought that
my advantages here would be so great as we both board in the same room together
(that is the teacher) that we concluded to offer him $30 per Ann which he
refused to take but sd. he would take 75 cts a week. This uncle and
myself thought was very extravagant but upon considering over everything we
concluded to give it to him for 3 or 4 months - as Willson's session had
commenced about the 1st of Decr. last & there is only 5 months
in a session which would have only 4 for me to go in. & I would have
to pay for the whole session even if I could only to go 2 months - whereas I
only pay him for the time I go - & my advantage here will be as great again
as at Willson's - for if I was to go on to Willson then the school would
be very much crowded & has only about 10 or 12 students & of rights I
can get any information on any subject whatever from Mr. Whitting who is my
teacher - for you may depend he is a very clever fellow & a Yankee too has
formerly taught in one of the principle Academies in Massachusetts & a graduated
lawyer but his state of health at present will not permit him to come to the
bar - & as my future study is that of law he says he can teach me every
thing necessary to commence that study. - I am now studying geometry &
trigonometry & expect to commence geography up on a new scale there is a
small book with questions in it & I am to find the answers from the globes
which will fix it in my mind without any summarizing. - I have to give
Majr. Grugett $75 per term for board. & to Mrs. Parker a private lady
in town $15 per term. for washing. The more I am in the country in which
you live, - you cannot imagine how my astonishment is excited to think that you
will live there & not come here - now let me again entreat you to sell yr.
possessions if possible & move to this or some other country better than
that as soon possible for the sooner the better. - I was on Wednesday the 27th
Decr. at a Masonic Ball held at Maj. Grugett's, where I enjoyed myself very
agreeably with 69 other gentlemen & about 100 ladies - the company
separated about 12 o'clock - all in harmony. - Polly Simpson is to be married
tomorrow evening to a Mr. Phelps a close neighbor of uncles who is recommended
to me as a very fine young man & very well off. Robert is to be
married in about 2 weeks to a Miss Dickey & Richd. is going to Orleans -
the people of this town & also in the country have & are now very
sickly with something like the influenzy & bad colds. - I have been very
unwell with it but am much better than I have been - & hope this letter will
you all enjoying health - Duke Watson? is still living with xxx & has got
no where else to go to but uncle says he will pay him whatever his work shall
be worth untill he can get some place to go to - I have one charge to give you,
that is, you must not fail to write to me immediately after the reception of
this letter & let me know how all acquaintances are & also if you have
sold yr. tobacco when, where, & what you got for it - do all you can to
keep Clary & Tommy at school for youth is the time to improve the mind
& cultivate the morals - I will write you again in the course of a month or
6 weeks & let you know how I progress &c &c -
Give my love and best
respects to all the family & give my friends particularly to Col Murphy
& Mr. Leasaur? - Tell William that I should be extremely glad to receive a
letter from him -
I got a pretty general
acquaintance with all the gentlemen in town & find extremely clever &
familiar. - I must close this letter, after saying as much as I have, but with
reluctance for it appears as I wish to write something but know not what - I
therefore subscribe myself your Sincere & ever affectionate son.
P.S. Let me know also if you are about to get
many subscribers to T. Reids proposals - yrs. &c.
JBR
2) John B. Reid to his father, Major John Reid (3/3/1816)
Outside envelope: Majr. John Reid
Caswell
N. Carolina
Madison County - March 3rd 1816
Dear Father,
I now write you agreeable to my promise by uncle,
who sets off for N.C. on Tuesday morning next. My state of health
continues as much as usual if any thing some better than it has been. I
have not commenced going to school yet nor I do not expect to commence untill
uncle returns in April next when I wish you to give him full instructions how I
shall proceed & allso write me on the subject. I am well aware that
my situation at present will not admit of my studying any thing for to tell the
truth I have something like a consumption & of course I must take very good
of myself & this summer I wish to ride over the country take a view of it
& visit my relations &c. which I think will increase my health as much
as I can any how else. - My cough is much worse at night when I lie down than any
other time - in the day it does not pester me any of account - I have as good
an appetite to eat as ever I had & eats as hearty but still I keep poor
& appear to fall away at - times I have a very severe pain over my eyes. -
The next thing is I shall also want to know by uncle how I am to get a horse
& when you wish me to return to N.C. - my informing you that I expected not
to go to school any more this spring. I hope will not keep you from
sending me the sum of money you promised in your letter of the 19th
Janr. as I shall have need of money in several cases & I owe Majr. Grugett
for board & Mr. Whitting for tuition & a person from home has use for
money in a great many instances more than if he was at home. - But I am in
hopes that after a while I shall be able to commence school again as I am very
desirious of finishing Euclids Elements the study in which I was engaged in -
& I also wish to study Geography. - On the early & proper education of
youth & friends in a great measure not only their own happiness but that of
their parents their friends and posterity. If they be enlightened by true
& useful science there is reason to hope they will be seen in after life
acting the dignified part of wisdom & virtue & thereby rendering
themselves ornaments to society and a blessing to the world. But the
opposite effects are certainly to be apprehended from an opposite source.-
As to our next president from different accounts it appears as public opinion
is various - the following gentlemen are named - James Monroe of Va., Wm H. Crawford of Geor.,
Gov. Tompkins of N.York, De Witt Clinton of Io.? and John Q. Adams of Mass. but I think Monroe will be elected. -
James Reid (son of John Reid of this county) was married to Polly Reid
(daughter of uncle Alex.) on Tuesday evening last & next day I was invited
to his fathers where I was treated as kindly as ever I was in my life. - Duke Wm son is now living with
uncle & likes our uncle is to give him $60 per term. He is very well
at present & I think doing very well. Uncles family are all well
& he can tell you more that I can write. Give my respects to all
friends & relations & also the family & believe me ever to be yr.
affectionate Son.
3) John B. Reid to his mother, Keziah Simpson
Reid (3/5/1816)
Outside envelope: Mrs. K. Reid
Caswell County
N. Carolina
Madison County Ky., March 5th 1816
Dear Mother,
I now write you to let you know I have not
forgotten you nor the many favors I have recd. from you. I was very glad
indeed to hear you had recovered from your fall you got in Chrismas & hope
this letter will find you & the rest of the family well. I am not
very well at present having a bad cough & pains over my eyes. But you
need give yourself no uneasiness for there is no doubt but what I shall get
well. - I have not been to see uncle & aunt Cleveland but will go as soon
as possible. I have been to see Dick Oldham & family & found them
very kind. I have also got acquainted with Keziah Thompson who made me
promise to come & see her which I should have done long since only the boys
are generally busy & cannot go with me. I have got acquainted old Mr.
T Reid & his family also uncle Alex's John Holby (Holley?) & several
others of your acquaintances - I intend going over to Lexington this spring with xx
Hardin among the Heart family. - I have got acquainted with Jere Burton who
came to uncles the week before last from Ten. & setts off tommorrow with
uncle for hovire? & he says his father & the relations were well &
that Dick Williamson came there & made up a school & had 38 schollars
at $8 but drank very hard & at length agreed to quit his school at the end of
4 months if they would pay him for that time which they did & he had $69 on
Tuesday morning & went into town & on Thursday he had not a cent &
went on in this way.
I have inclosed you a cap which I wish you to accept as a memorial of my
gratitude & love for you - but I don't want you to lay it by & not use
it. I sent it for you to wear. I have also sent Clarrissa a brest pin which she must keep
to remember me - Duke Williamson is well & living with uncle & working
in the crops he gets $50 & clothes himself he says he is coming to N.C.
next winter. Mr. Hardin & cousin Betsey are well & their son
continues to improve daily. Uncle's family are all well. Give my
love to Tommy & Clarrissa & believe me ever to be yr. affectionate son.
4) Richard "Duke" Simpson to his
brother-in-law, Major John Reid (4/24/1816)
Outside envelope: Richmond Ky
April 25
Majr, John Reid
Caswell Coty No. Carolina
P.Office Lenox Castle
Kentucky, Madison County, 24th April 1816
DSir,
I have taken up my pen
to write you with more reluctance than ever I experienced on any former
occasion when writing to a friend. - But duty enjoins it & painfull
as the recital is - I will faithfully detail it. - Your son had continued
very nigh in the same condition I left him (perhaps rather declining) till
about ten or twelve days before my return, when he was violently attackted with
the Measels - that brought on him a high fever & he desired to have
Doctr. Rollins sent for, which was accordingly done & the Doctr. Has attended
him ever since & is yet attending on him.
His fever still continues tho tis now slight, his cough has ceasd. & he
spits freely & the Doctr. says all the symptoms are favourable. -
But, (tho I don't wish to alarm you) I am notwithstanding the Doctors opinion,
very fearfull he is approaching his dissolution fast - in a few days I shall be
able to form a better opinion & will give it to you honestly - when his
fever is ok he is a chearfull as formerly, seems fond of company & conversation
- when his fever is on, he sleeps almost continually, talks in his sleep &
appears to be often dreaming - in his sleep, he very frequently blames himself
for bringing the Measles into my family & well say he ought not to have
done so - tho I have not heard say anything xxx when awake - He read yours and
Billys letters, with a great deal of satisfaction & made very particular
enquiries about his Mother & Sister. - My family is well except the
Measles - & my heart is too full to write you any more. I am DSir
with sentiments of the highest consideration & respect Yr.HLeeS
P.S. I got home on Saturday the 20th
of this month-
& two weeks after the Rect. of this, your
may expect another.
5) Richard "Duke" Simpson to his
brother-in-law, Major John Reid (5/8/1816)
Outside envelope: Richmond Ky
May 9
Majr, John Reid
Caswell County
No. Carolina
P.Office at Lenox Castle
Kentucky, Madison County, 8th May 1816
DSir,
It has become my painfull duty, to be the
harbinger to you of the melancholy & heart rending news of the death of
your son, who departed this life on Friday last at a half past 10
o'clock. The Measles I have no doubt hastened his exit, from the time he
was taken with that complaint, he wasted & declined very fast. On the
Sunday before I got home, he in the afternoon rode home with Mr. Hardin &
Betsey with an intention of staying till Wednesday, but he declined so fast on
Wednesday he was unable to get back & consequently continued with Mr.
Harden till his death. - he was confined to his bed only about two weeks,
during which time he had considerable company it appeard to me he was admired
by all that knew him & was waited on with the utmost attention.-
After reading the letter I brought him & asking me a number of questions
about the family &c, the next day after I got home - he was no more heard
to mention any of you till about two days before his death, & then in his
sleep, he at different times talkd of all the family. - He appeard Chearfull
& did not seem to suffer any pain during his indisposition nor did he ever
once complain, or say he was sick. We had an elegant Coffin made for him,
of Curled Cherry, with a raisd top & having nicely dressd & shouded?
him - have buried him at Mr. Hardens by the side of his little children. - I
shall have no funeral appointed till I hear from you, tis possible if you
should move to this country, the family may wish to attend it.
A few days before his death he gave Mr. Harden a bill of different little debts
he owed in Town & requested him to go in & pay them off & bring him
the rects. which Mr. Harden did & after reading them, he put them into his
pocket book & that in his Coat pocket.
His money, Watch, Cloaths, Saddle, bridle, Saddlebags, Books, &c are all
here & shall be particularly taken care of - subject to your order.-
My family has & will all put on morning for him & so will a number of
his acquaintances in the Town & Country & there will be a great deal
more respect so to his memory, then you can possibly suppose a youth of his age
could command. - He died quite easy, without a groan or struggle & was
the most amiable looking corpse I ever beheld, having that agreeable smile on
his countenance, that was common with through life. - My family is not
yet clear of the Measles tho I hope none of them dangerous. - I am Sir real
friend & HreS
6) Richard "Duke" Simpson to his nephew, William B. Simpson
(4/7/1845)
Outside envelope: Mr. Willam B. Reid
Fayette County Tennessee
P.Office White Hall
Independence, Missouri, 7th April 1845
Dear Billy,
I recd. your friendly & affectionate letter
of the 10th of March a few days ago, which gave me not a little
pleasure to hear my old sister is still living and enjoying good health, as
also your own family, with the exception of yourself.
I have not yet fully decided whether I will attempt to comply with your
invitation to visit you and Sister this spring or not. - I have a strong
inclination to do so, but very much dread the undertaking - but I will decide
in a few days. & If I come, I will leave here about the 10th
of May & if nothing happens will be with you about the 18th or
20th of the month. - If I come, my Daughter Henrietta Harris will
come with me at least she says so now - it would give me inexpressable
satisfaction to visit you & spend a few weeks with Sister & your family
& I think if my health continues tolerable good I attempt it, but should I
decline the undertaking I will apprise you of it & not keep you in
suspense.
I have sold all my property, real & personal, and divided the money equally
amoungst my children - except what I think may be necessary for my own support
& am now living next to my Daughter above xxxed.
My children is at last
all in the state, except my eldest son John who resides in Baltimore, Maryland. & xxx xxx 28 years
past this number of children, grandchildren & great grandchildren will
astonish you. - We counted them up a short time since and then there is
now living 104 or 5 & increasing astonishingly - they are as far as I
know on good health and I think doing well generally. - My own health is
as good as a man of my age ought to expect. - & my hand trembles so I can't
write any more but wish I shall see you shortly. Affectionately, your
uncle.
7) Richard "Duke" Simpson to his
nephew, William B. Simpson (9/9/1845)
Outside envelope: Westport Mo
Mr. Willam B. Reid
Fayette County Tennessee
P.Office White Hall
Independence, Mo., 9th Septr. 1845
Dear Nephew,
I wrote you sometime ago
that my Daughter Henrietta and myself contemplated paying a visit to Sister
Keziah and your family and expected to start about the 1st of this
month - we prepared for the trip & had all things in readiness when to our
disappointment, my son Duke & Daughters Henrietta & Julia Ann were all
three taken down with the fever and had a violent attack - the first two are
recovering and I trust out of danger, but Julia Ann has been expected to die
every hour for the last ten days, however we think a favourable change took
place yesterday evening and we now have some hopes she may recover - this has
prevented us for the present from attempting to set out, & before she can
sufficiently recover to be left in safety, the season will be too far advanced
for a man of my age to undertake it. - add to this the Missouri River is so
low, that the steam Boats have ceased to run, consequently we could not come if
nothing else prevented - however we have not declined the visit & if I live
and enjoy my health untill next spring, I will attempt it if I find sister
still lives & I hope you will write me from time to time informing me of
her health.-
We had six weeks of extremely wet weather in May & June at the close of it
our crops looked very bad, but since that time the season has been favourable,
and they have come out surprisingly & will be very abundant. - My
whole family except those I have mentioned I think are in good health as I
sincerely hope these times may find Sister & your family - to all of whom
present my best wishes & believe affectionately,
Your Uncle,
[written in margin]
When you write again, tell me about your mother in law - if dead,
when and where she died & where her other children are.
8) Richard "Duke" Simpson to his
sister, Keziah Simpson Reid (5/4/1847)
Outside envelope: Westport Mo
May
Mrs. Keziah Reid
Fayette County Tennessee
P.Office White Hall
May 24th/47
West Port Jackson County< Mo., May 4th 1847
Dear Sister,
I recd. your letter of the 13th of last month some days ago &
would have answerd it before this time, but my health would not permit of
it. - I have been unwell since about the first of January but thank providence
I feel to be recovering. - I think Sister tis reduced to a certainty that we
never shall have the pleasure of meeting in this world any more, I would have
tried to have visited you, but my health was bad & the whole family opposed
it - but sister if we can prepare, & through the mercy of God &
intercession of our Saviour to meet where parting will be no more - let this
satisfy us, for our separation here.
I am extremely sorry to hear of Williams death, leaving behind him a wife &
such a number of children - but I am told his wife is a sensible fine woman,
let us hope for the best.
You ask to hear something from Betsey Harden. She lives up the Missouri River, in the Platt Country
some hundred & fifty above me. I but seldom hear from her, but as
usual I expect they are not doing very well. She has seven children, they
are all grown & married but the youngest & how they are making out I
can't say. The rest of my children is progressing well & all growing
rich & are highly respectable. - I am sorry Mr. Smith & Clarissa
is not in your neighborhood as you have but the one Daughter it would afford
you great consolation to have Clare by you. -
After my wifes death, I soon discovered that I could not manage a house &
plantation too. & I determined to give up all my property to my
children & they advertised a public sale, in a certain day & sold land,
negroes, & every thing and made an equal division amoungst them - receiving
to myself Twenty five hundred dollars, which I thought sufficient for me the
residue of my life. - We have had a severe winter & I think the people is
more sickly than usual at this season of the year.
My children is enjoying as good health as is to be expected. My hand
cramps so that I can't write any more - give my love to Billy, Widow &
children & believe me sincerely your affectionate Brother.
9) Duke Williamson Simpson to his aunt,
Keziah Simpson Reid (10/25/1847)
Outside envelope: West Port Mo
Oct. 25th
Mrs. Keziah Reid
Tulip Post Office
Dallas County
Arkansas
West Port Mo., October 25th 1847
Dear Aunt,
For the last year, my father finds it impossible to do what writing he wishes, and
it hurts him so, to write, that I think it is more than probable that he will
hardly ever write another letter. - At his instance I write you these
lines, as he feels very curious that you shall hear from him. - He made two
attempts to write you a letter, and failed. - He feels very solicitous to
hear from you, as long as you and himself lives and I will do his writing
hereafter.
For the last year, my fathers health has been excellent for a man of his age,
and he looks young comparatively speaking for a man of his age, he is medling?
fleshy?, and is full of life, and is as as talkative and fond of company and
friends as a boy. - He is entirely temperate, drinks no spirits of any kind,
quit some eighteen months ago and says that he feels better and enjoys himself
better than he ever did before. - He determined within himself to quit using
any spirits. - He never joined any Temperance Society. This I consider a
very extraordinary case, a man that has been in the habit of using spirits for
65 or 70 years to a small extent, should entirely quite is a rare occurrence. -
He is living with his daughter Henrietta Harris since the death of my mother,
apparently as well contented as any person, where he enjoys the society of his
children almost every week, all living near to him, except brother John, and
Betsey, who married Hardin. - John lives in Baltimore, and Betsey lives above us
on the Mo. River some 150 miles. -
My fathers children who live in Mo. are all well off, in good circumstances and are
making money, clear of any dissipation, and pretty much devoted to work and
business.
My fathers offspring are quite numerous, he has a large number of children and
grandchildren. - Betsey Hardin and her husband have managed worse than any of
our family in point of wealth. - I have been unfortunate in some
respects, I have my third wife, whom I married about 18 months ago, she was a
Mrs. Winchester raised near Gallatin in Tennessee, she was a widow of
Levitius Winchester (who was the son of Genl. James Winchester who died in
Sumner County Tennessee). My present wife was a daughter of Isaac
Bledsoe, near Bledsoe's lick in Sumner County Tenn. - I have six living children, 4 Sons
& 2 Daughters, all hale, and healthy. - At present I am living in West Port, have been selling
goods here since March 1839. I also own a fine farm and landed estate 3
miles south of this place, and my prospects are as good as I ought to wish in
money matters.
My father at one time promised himself to pay you a visit in cousin Williams
life time, and was two or three times on the very eve of starting , but he
dislikes the idea of going from home and is and always was the most home person
that you ever saw. - I doubt now whether he ever will have the pleasure of
seeing of you in time. - But I must insist on your writing to him, you
have no idea how he is delighted on receiving a letter from you. - It has
been a great while since I had the pleasure of seeing of you, or any of your
family. - Once, when a boy, it was a great treat to go visiting to uncle
Reids and my recollections of circumstances and things are as bright and clear
as yesterday. - Cousin Clarissa was very young and timid in those days,
and I reckon she scarcely remembers me. Tender to her and her husband my
best wishes for their future happiness and welfare.
There are but a few persons who have enjoyed the same degree of health as you
and my father and who have lived to the same age. - Time is sweeping of
us off. - In looking back I find you have lost cousin John and Wm. and my
father has buried his wife and Bros. Robert, Richard, George and Polly an a
great many of my youthful acquaintances and schoolmates are gone the way of all
the earth. - My father is well pleased at the idea of you going to live
with Clarissa and thinks you will be much better contentious and is glad to
hear that you are in a good neighborhood and? have good society. These
things render life much more agreeable. - I find from you letter to
father that you are fond of going to church, which I rejoice exceedingly to
hear, being in accordance with my own notions of right. - I was Baptized in 1804 in Ky. and have been attached
to the Christian body since that time and in this day and time they call me a
Reformer or Campbellites (that is to say the Sects). - But with me
nicknames are nothing. - You request to know of my father your age and
his. - You were born on the 8th February 1767 and he was born on the 3rd of March 1770.
- My fathers health is good at present and our relations generally speaking are
well. - We have had some sickness among us this season, my family has
been somewhat unwell, that is my wife's health is not good, though better than
it has been. Some of my slaves have been unwell, indeed I have lost one
young woman this season. - Mr. Harris's family have been somewhat unwell this
season, though he has not lost any of them. - Our country generally
speaking has been healthy. - Give my respects to Mr. Smith and Clarissa and
family, and accept of my best wishes for your health and happiness, both in time and Eternity. -
Truly I remain your Nephew,
[Calculations of Keziah and Richard's age were handwritten on the bottom
of the letter based on the birth days mentioned above. The letter is dated
in 1847 but the calculations were done for the years 1848 and 1855]
1848
1855
1855 176717671770
81
88
85
From the John Reid Papers #3882
Southern Historical Collection, Wilson Library
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
Richard Simpson was the chairman of a citizens committee formed to determine what to do about
the problem of the Mormons in Independence, MO. A son-in-law, James M. Hunter, was also a member of this committee.
His son, George, was a leader in the famous tar and feathering of a Mormon bishop. Another son, Duke, wrote to his
Aunt Kesiah Simpson Reid in 1847 that he was a follower of the Campbellites
(read the letter here). The Campbellites divided into two sects,
the Church of Christ and the Disciples of Christ and were at odds with the Mormons.
Here are some contemporary newspaper articles during this period:
By Charless & Pasehall.] St. Louis, September 6, 1831
[Vol. 10 - No. 494.
The Mormonites. -- We learn from the Painesville Gazette, that this infatuated people are again in
motion. In their own cant phrase, "they are going to inherit the promise of God to Abraham and his seed."
Their destination is some indefinite spot on the Missouri river they say about 1500 miles distant. About eighty of
them have recently been ordained and some have gone, others are about going, two and two, part by the western rivers
and part by land, to their distant retreat, far away from the cheering voice of civilized man. Those who have
disposed of their property go now, and such as have property, are making market for it so eagerly as often to
disregard pecuniary interests, and all are to follow with all convenient dispatch. They still persist in their power
to work miracles. They say they have often seen them done -- the sick are healed -- the lame walk -- devils
are cast out -- and these assertions are made by men heretofore considered rational men, and men of truth. The
Gazette expresses the opinion, that although the leaders of this sect are gross impostors, a great portion of its
members are sincere and honest.
(Some of the leaders of this sect, we are told, passed through this place two or three weeks since, on their return
to Ohio. We understand, that they have determined to migrate to Jackson County, on the extreme edge of this State;
for which purpose they have purchased a sufficiency of land whereupon to locate the whole of the believers of
Mormonism. We have some hope that the latter part of the paragraph may be true, as, in any other event, we should
not rejoice much in the acquisition of so many deluded, insane enthusiasts.)
Note 1: The Republican was a little late in reprinting the above notice from the Painesville Geauga Gazette of June 21,
1831. As the St. Louis journalist adds, "the leaders... passed through this place two or three weeks since."
The grand (?) first LDS Conference held in "Zion" took place on Aug. 4th, with Elders Joseph Smith, jr.,
Sidney Rigdon, and other prominent Saints in attendance. The events of that period are related in considerable detail
in the published letters of Ezra Booth, beginning in the Oct. 13, 1831 issue of the Ohio Star. According to his report
and other historical sources, Smith, and Rigdon passed through St. Louis, on their way back to Kirtland, in mid August
of 1831.
Note 2: The newspapers of that early period were not yet saying much about Joseph Smith religious claims, Elder Ezra
Booth's comments about the Mormon leaders, the Saints' intended migration to Missouri, etc. Early papers like the
Republican and the St Louis Beacon, although they said little about the early Mormons, offer a wealth of supplementary
information on the situation of the Saints along the Missouri frontier in 1831-32. For example, the Beacon's issues of
May 31 and June 9, 1831 list letters waiting in the St. Louis post office for a certain "Joseph Smith."
Possibly these were addressed to the Mormon leader, whose correspondents felt they could reach him in Missouri via the
St. Louis post office. A stronger case can be made for the identity of the "Sidney Rigdon" who, according to
the Beacon's issues of Aug. 2 and Aug. 18, 1831, also had letters waiting for him at the post office. The writer of
these letters apparently expected Rigdon to pass through St. Louis on his way back to Ohio, after attending the LDS
Conference at Independence.
By Charless &Pasehall.] St. Louis, April ?, 1833
[Vol. ? - No. ?.
MORMONISM. -- The citizens of this place, for the past two weeks, have had an opportunity of hearing this new religion
fully explained. Curiosity attracted many respectible congregations to hear them, and the majority were willing
to give them a chance to prove their faith, but we have not heard that they brought conviction to any mind of a
single individual. The only effect their preaching has had is, a tendency to confirm the sceptical, after hearing
such glaring absurdities to be proved by the Bible.
Note: This report from St. Louis was reprinted in the May 9, 1833 issue of the Ravenna Western Star. The
original article in the Republican has not yet been located. Apparently Mormon missionaries were then preaching
in St. Louis, without making many converts.
By Charless &Pasehall.]
St. Louis, Friday, May 3, 1833
[Vol. ? - No. ?.
MORMONISM. --
We perceive by a letter from Independence, Missouri to the Editor of the Cincinnati Journal that difficulties have
already begun in the Mormon community at Mount Zion in that quarter: one of the members having sued the Bishop in a
court of justice, for fifty dollars, which had been sent by plaintiff to said Bishop from Ohio, "to purchase
an inheritance for himself and the saints of God in Zion in these last days." This was certainly a most
impious act, but "nevertheless and notwithstanding," the jury found for the plaintiff; it appearing that
though the good bishop had indeed appropriated the money "to the purchase of an inheritance," yet he had,
unthoughtedly no doubt, procured the deed to be drawn in his own name, to his heirs, &c., and no one else in Zion nor
out of it. The writer states that on this decision several other members are ready to make similar demands on the good
bishop. Wonder if this is one of the bishop's miracles? It appears by another letter from the same gentleman, (Mr.
Pixley, a Baptist clergyman,) that since their settlement at Mount Zion -- or Jerusalem, as they sometimes term it --
four or five hundred of these deluded wretches, including men, women, and children, have arrived there. Several others
are said to be preparing to start there from Cincinnati, in the course of a few weeks. -- Ohio Courant.
Note 1: The above article evidently originated in the Zanesville Ohio Republican of Apr. 27, 1833.
The issue of the Cincinnati Journal containing the Rev. Benton Pixley letter has not yet been located.
Note 2: The journalist's mention of "another letter from the same gentleman," references Rev. Pixley's
Oct. 12, 1832 communication from Missouri to the Christian Watchman, reprinted in the Nov. 29, 1832 issue of
the Independent Messenger. Another late 1832 Pixley letter, written to the Baptist Weekly Journal,
was reprinted in the Apr. 6, 1833 issue of the Christian Register.
By Charless &Pasehall.] St. Louis, Friday, August 9, 1833 [Vol. 12 - No. ?
REGULATING THE MORMONITES. --
Some very extraordinary proceedings have recently taken place in Jackson county, in this state, against the sect of
fanatics called Mormons. These proceedings may find some justification in the necessity of the case, but they are
wholly at war with the genius of our institutions, and as subversive of good order as the conduct of the fanatics
themselves. Perhaps, however, it was the only method which could have been effectually put in practice to get this
odious description of population out of the way. Banished as they are from that frontier, it may well be asked to what
place will they now remove; and will they enjoy any better security in the new abode which they may select? But to
the proceedings:
A meeting of the citizens of Jackson county, to the number of four or five hundred, was held at Independence on the
20th of July. Their avowed object was to take measures to rid themselves of the Mormonites.
Col. Richard Simpson was called to the chair, and Jonas H. Flournoy and Samuel
D. Lucas appointed secretaries. A committee was then appointed to report an address to the public, in relation to the
object of the meeting. After having retired for some time, they submitted an address, which was unanimously adopted;
and in which the conduct and views of the obnoxious sect are exposed. They represent that the Mormonites number some
1,200 souls in that county, and that each successive spring and autumn pours forth its swarms among them, with a
gradual falling off in the character of those who compose them, until they have now nearly reached the low condition
of the black population. That the citizens have been daily told that they are to be cut off, and their lands
appropriated to the Mormons for inheritances; but they are not fully agreed among themselves as to the manner in which
this shall be accomplished, whether by the destroying angel, the judgement of God, or the arm of power. The comittee
express their fears that, should this population continue to increase, they will soon have all the offices of the
county in their hands; and that the lives and property of other citizens would be insecure, under the administration
of men who are so ignorant and superstitious as to believe that they have been the subjects of miraculous and
supernatural cures; hold converse with God and his angels and possess and exercise the gift of divination, and of
unknown tongues; and, are withal, so poor as to be unable to procure bread and meat. The committee say that one of
the means resorted to by them, in order to drive us to emigrate, is an indirect invitation to the free brethren of
color in Illinois, to come like the rest to the land of Zion. True, the Mormons say this was not intended to
invite but to prevent emigration; but this weak attempt to quiet our apprehensions is but a poor
compliment to our understanding." The invitation alluded to, contained all the necessary directions and cautions
to enable the free blacks, on their arrival there, to claim and exercise their right of citizenship. Finally, the
committee say --
Of their pretended revelations from heaven -- their personal intercourse with God and his angels -- the maladies they
pretend to heal by the laying on of hands -- and the contemptible gibberish with which they habitually profane the
Sabbath, and which they dignify with the appelation of unknown tongues, we have nothing to say. Vengeance belongs to
God alone. But as to the other matters set forth in this paper, we feel called on by every consideration of
self-preservation, good society, public morals, and the fair prospects, that if not blasted in the germ, await this
young and beautiful country, at once to declare, and we do most solemnly declare.
1. That no Mormon in future move and shall settle in this county.
2. That those now here, who shall give a definite pledge of their intention
within a reasonable time to remove out of the county, shall be allowed to
remain unmolested until they have sufficient time to sell their property and
close their business without any material sacrifice.
3. That the editor of the 'Star' be required forthwith to close his office,
and discontinue the business of printing in this county; and as to all other
stores and shops belonging to the sect, their owners must in every case
strictly comply with the terms of the second article of this declaration, and
upon failure, prompt and efficient measures will be taken to close the same.
4. That the Mormon leaders here, are required to use their influence in
preventing any further emigration of their distant brethren to this county,
and to counsel and advise their brethren here to comply with the above requisitions.
5. That those who fail to comply with these requisitions, be referred to
those of their brethren who have the gifts of divination, and unknown
tongues, to inform them of the lot that awaits them.
Which address being read and considered, was unanimously adopted. And
thereupon it was resolved that a committe of twelve be appointed forthwith to
wait on the Mormon leaders, and see that the foregoing requisitions are
strictly complied with by them; and upon their refusal that said committee
do, as the organ of this county, inform that it is our unwavering purpose and
fixed determination, after the fullest consideration of all the consequences
and responsibilities under which we act, to use such means as shall ensure
their full and complete adoption, and that said committee, so far as may be
within their power report to this present meeting. And the following
gentlemen were named as said committee: Robert Johnson, James Campbell, col,
Moses Wilson, Joel F. Chiles, hon. Richard Fristoe, Abner F. Staples, Garr
Johnson, Lewis Franklin, Russel Hicks, esq., col. S. D. Lucas, Thomas Wilson,
and James M. Hunter, to whom was added Col. R. Simpson, Chairman.
And after an adjournment of two hours, the meeting again convened, and the
committee of twelve reported that they had called on Mr. Phelps, the editor
of the "Star," Edward Partridge, the bishop of the sect, and Mr.
Gilbert, the keeper of the Lord's store house, and some others, and that they
declined giving any direct answer to the requisitions made of them, and
wished an unreasonable time for consultation, not only with their brethren here, but in Ohio.
Whereupon it was unanimously resolved by the meeting that the
"Star" printing office should be razed to the ground, the type and
press secured. Which resolution was, with the utmost order, and the least
noise or disturbance possible, forthwith, carried into execution, as also
some other steps of a similar tendency; but no blood was spilled nor any
blows inflicted. The meeting then adjourned till the 23d instant, to meet
again to know further concerning the determination of the Mormons.
The citizens again convened on the 23d day of July, 1833, which was composed
of gentlemen from all parts of the county, and much more unanimousely
attended than the meeting on the 20th instant.
The meeting was organized by the chairman taking his seat, when the following
gentlemen were appointed a committee, to wit:
Henry Chiles, Esq., Dr. N. K. Olmstead, H. L. Brazile, Esq., Zachariah
Waller, Samuel Weston Esq., Wm. L. Irwin, Leonides Oldham, S. C. Owens Esq., George Simpson, Capt. Benjamin Majors,
James C. Sadler, Col. Willian Bowers, Henry Younger, Russel Hicks Esq., Aaron
Overton, John Harris, and Harmon Gregg, to wait upon the Mormon leaders, who
had intimated a wish to have conference with said committee. After an
adjournment of two hours, the meeting again convened, when the committee
reported, to the meeting that they had waited on most of the Mormon leaders,
consisting of the bishop, Mr. Partridge, Mr. Phelps, editor of the Star, Mr.
Gilbert, the keeper of the Lord's store house, and Messrs. Carrol, Whitmer,
and Moseley, elders of the church, and that the said committee had entered
into an amicible agreement with them, which they had reduced to writing,
which they submitted; and that the committee have assured Mr. Phelps that
whenever he was ready to move, that the amount of all his losses should be
paid to him by the citizens. The written agreement is as follows:
"Memorandum of agreement between the undersigned of the Mormon society
in Jackson county Missouri, and a committee appointed by a public meeting of
the citizens of said county, made the 23d day of July, 1833.
"It is understood that the undersigned, members of the society, do give
their solemn pledges each for himself, as follows, to wit:
"That Oliver Cowdery, W. W. Phelps, William McClealand, Edward
Partridge, Lyman Wight, Simeon Carter, Peter and John Whitmer, and Harvey
Whitlock, shall remove with their families out of this county, on or before
the first day of January next; and that they, as well as the two hereinafter
named, use all their influence to induce all the brethren now here to remove
as soon as possible -- one half, say, by the first of January next, and all
by the first day of April next. To advise and try all means in their power to
stop any more of their sect from moving to this county; and as to those now
on the road, they will use their influence to prevent their settling
permanently in the county, but that they shall only make arrangements for
temporary shelter, till a new location is agreed on for the society. John
Carrol and Algernon Gilbert are allowed to remain as general agents to wind
up the business of the society, so long as necessity shall require; and said
Gilbert may sell out his merchandise now on hand, but is to make no new importations.
"The 'Star' is not again to be published, nor a press set up by any of the society in this county.
"If the said Edward Partridge and W. W. Phelps move their families by
the first day of January, as aforesaid, that they themselves will be allowed
to go and come in order to transact and wind up their business.
"The committee pledge themselves to use all their influence to prevent
any violence being used so as long as a compliance with the foregoing terms
is observed by the parties concerned; to which agreement is subscribed the
names of the above named committee, as also those of the Mormon brethren
named in the report as having been present."
The report of the committee was unanimously adopted by the meeting and it was then adjourned.
Note: This article was widely reprinted in the Eastern papers, providing many
American readers with their first detailed information on the Mormons in Missouri.
By Charless &Pasehall.] St. Louis
[Vol. ? - No. ?
TAR AND FEATHERING OF A MORMAN BISHOP. --
On the 20th [July 1833], the mob collected, and demanded the discontinuance of the
printing in Jackson county: a closing of the store: and a cessation of all mechanical labors. The brethren refused
compliance, and the consequence was, that the house of W. W. Phelps, which contained the printing establishment,
was thrown down; the materials taken possession of by the mob; many papers destroyed, and the family and furniture
thrown out doors.
The mob then proceeded to violence
towards [819] Edward Partridge, the bishop of the church, as he relates in his
autobiography;
I was taken from my house by the mob, George Simpson being their leader,
who escorted me about half a mile, to the court house, on the public square in Independence; and then and there,
a few rods from said court house, surrounded by hundreds of the mob, I was stripped of my hat, coat and vest, and
daubed with tar from head to foot, and then had a quantity of feathers put upon me, and all this, because I would
not agree to leave the county, my home where I had lived two years.
Before tarring and feathering me, I was permitted to speak. I told them that the saints had had to suffer persecution
in all ages of the world, that I had done nothing which ought to offend any one. That if they abused me, they would
abuse an innocent person. That I was willing to suffer for the sake of Christ; but, to leave the country I was not
then willing to consent to it.
By this time the multitude made so much noise that
I could not be heard: some were cursing and swearing, saying, call upon your
Jesus &c.; others were equally noisy in trying to still the rest, that they
might be enabled to hear what I was saying.
Until after I had spoken, I knew not what they
intended to do with me, whether to kill me, to whip me, or what else I knew
not. I bore my abuse with so much resignation and meekness, that it
appeared to astound the multitude, who permitted me to retire in silence, many
looking very solemn, their sympathies having been touched as I thought; and, as
to myself, I was so filled with the spirit and love of God, that I had no
hatred towards my persecutors, or any one else.
Charles Allen was next stripped and tarred and feathered, because he would not agree to leave the county, or deny the
Book of Mormon. Others were brought up to be served likewise or whipped, but from some cause, the mob ceased
operations, and adjourned until Tuesday the 23rd. Elder Gilbert, the keeper of the store agreed to close that; and
that may have been one reason, why the work of destruction was suddenly stopped for two days.
In the course of this day's wicked outrageous and unlawful proceedings, many solemn realities of human
degredation, as well as thrilling incidents were presented to the saints.
An armed and well organized mob in a government professing to be governed
by law, with the Lieutenant Governor, (Lilburn W. Boggs,) the second officer in
the state, calmly looking on, and secretly aiding every movement, saying to the
saints, "you now know what our Jackson boys can do, and you must leave the
country," and all the justices, judges, constables, sheriffs, and military
officers, headed by such western missionaries and clergymen as the Reverends McCoy,
Kavanaugh, Hunter, Fitzhugh, Pixley, Likens, Lovelady, and Bogard, consisting
of Methodists, Baptists, Presbyterians, and all the different sects of
religionists that inhabited that country; with that great moral reformer, and
Register of the Land Office at Lexington, forty miles east, known as the head
and father of the Cumberland Presbyterians, even the Reverend Finis Ewing
publicly publishing that the "Mormons were the common enemies of mankind,
and ought to be destroyed;" all these solemn realities were enough to melt
the heart of a savage; while there was not a solitary offence on record, or
proof that a saint had broken the law of the land.
And when Bishop Partridge: who was
without guile, and Elders Charles Allen, walked off, amid the horrid yells of
an infuriated mob, coated like some un-named, unknown biped, and one of the
sisters cried aloud; "while you, who have done this wicked deed, must
suffer the vengeance of God; they, having endured persecution, can rejoice, for
henceforth, for them, is laid up a crown, eternal in the heavens;" surely
there was a time of awful reflection, that man, unrestrained, like the brute
beast, may torment the body; but God in return, will punish the soul.
Charless &Pasehall.] St. Louis, Tuesday, November 12, 1833 [Vol. 12 - No. 641.
CIVIL WAR.
We lament to say that the following account, in its most essential
features, is confirmed by other passengers in the steam boat Charleston.
On Board Steam Boat Charleston, ST. LOUIS, Nov. 9th, 1833.
MESSERS. EDITORS --
I take this opportunity to give you and your readers a brief sketch of the
most flagrant and outrageous violation of the constitution of our country
than has taken place since it was framed.
I am a member of the church of Christ, (reproachfully called Mormons
or Mormonites) and am directly from Independence, the seat of war and
bloodshed in the United States.
On Thursday night, Oct. 31, some forty or fifty of the citizens of Jackson county, Mo. assembled
above the Blue, (a river about eight or ten miles west of Independence,) and, in part demolished
twelve of the dwelling houses of our people who
occupied them at the time. The inmates were obliged to escape to the woods,
women and children running in every direction, halloing and screaming; and
the men, being taken by surprise in the dead hour of the night, were unprepared
to defend themselves if they had been disposed. They took two of our men and
beat them with stones and clubs, leaving only a breath of life in them. After
this the mob dispersed, it being about 3 o'clock in the morning.
Friday night, Nov. 1, the mob broke open the store of Gilbert &Whitney,
and scattered their goods through the streets. They demolished Gilbert's
brick dwelling house, and broke in the doors and windows of all the dwellings
in Independence belonging to our people. Saturday our people left their
dwellings, and took their most valuable articles of furniture, clothing,
&c., that they might be better prepared for self-defence. Night came on,
and the mob came along with it, and commenced their ravages again above the
Blue, and after they had fired five or six guns upon our people without
effect, our people fired upon them, and one of their number exclaimed,
"O my God! I am shot!" The mob then dispersed, taking their wounded
companion along with them, who was shot through the thigh.
On Monday last the mob collected again, in the town of Independence, to the
number of two or three hundred, well armed; they called it
"Calling Out The Militia." They undoubtedly thought that the above
appellation would sound better than its real and legitimate name, which is
MOB, and if they could lessen the magnitude of their crime in the eyes of the
community by so doing, -- they, no doubt, would be highly gratified. But this
cunning plot to deceive, covers their iniquity no more than the fig leaves
covered our first parents in the garden from the piercing eye of Jehovah. At
night a part of the number that had collected in town, went above Blue, to
drive our people away, and destroy our property; but they were met by a party
of our people, and being prepared, they poured a deadly fire upon them. Two
or three of their number fell dead on the ground, and a number mortally
wounded. Among the former, was Hugh L. Breazeale, Att'y at Law. Tuesday
morning, there was a number of the mob missing and could not be accounted
for, I was told.
I left Independence and came down the river to Liberty; landing where we
stopped to take in freight; and while we were there, (Wednesday 11 o'clock,
A. M.) a messenger rode up saying that he had just came from the seat of war,
and that the night before, another battle was fought in which Mr. Hicks,
Att'y at Law, fell, having three balls and some buck shot through his body;
and about twenty more of the mob, shared a similar fate. Mr. H. was one of
the heads of the mob. Report says also that one or two of our men were killed
and as many wounded. The cannonading in the engagement was heard on board the
boat very distinctly.
I was an eye witness to a part of the above statements; but things were in a
state of great confusion and agitation at the time, and should there be an
error in the above, I hope to find pardon in the eyes of a candid people. One
more item I will notice. -- At the time Messrs G. &W.'s store was broken
open, Mr. G. with a number of others, succeeded in taking the one who first
broke open the door, and brought him forthwith before a magistrate to see if
something could not be done with him; but the magistrate refused to do
anything about it.
This was an unwise move of Mr. G.; but on seeing his property destroyed in that
barbarous manner, and the agitation of mind which he was necessarily laboring
under, he was led to do as he did. After they liberated the man, he took them
with a warrant immediately for false imprisonment and put them in prison,
viz: Mr. Gilbert, Phelps the printer, and one more; and as near as I can
learn the mob was determined never to let them escape from prison alive.
I am one, who went to the Governor with a petition for assistance to obtain
our rights, or redress of our wrongs and aggrievances received from the
citizens of Jackson county, in July last. But as the circumstances then were,
the Governor said he could do nothing, but advised us to take the regular
steps of the law, which, at that time, was our only course, and this we
attempted to do; but instead of peace being promoted by it, it increased
their rage and led them to commit the horrid crimes named above.
I am satisfied that it is useless to undertake to enforce the laws in that
county under the present circumstances, because there is no one to enforce
them. Every officer, civil and military, with one or two exceptions, is
either directly or indirectly engaged in the mob.
Under these painful circumstances, what remains to be done? Must we be driven
from our homes? Must we leave the soil for which we have paid our money? --
Most our women and children be turned out of doors with nothing but the
clouded canopy to cover them and the perpetration of the above crimes escape
unpunished? Or must we fight our enemies three to one, or lie down and die
and our names be blotted out from among men? Let the Executive of our State
and nation consider these questions; and if they will answer them in the
negative, let them signify it by raising the helping hand. Again, I ask in
behalf of my brethren: Will not the Governor or President lend a helping hand
in this deadly calamity? Shall the crisis of the innocent and distressed,
salute the ears of the Executive in vain? God forbid! For while the
constitution of the United States, which was given by the inspiration of
Almighty God through the instrumentality of our fathers, shall stand, I trust
that those who are honored with the Executive, will see that the laws are
magnified and made honorable. -- Perhaps some of my friends, on reading this
letter, will be ready to ask me what I think of my religion now: I have no
reply, other than this: Paul said, "He that will live godly in Christ
Jesus shall suffer persecution."
Editors throughout the United States, are requested to publish this letter, if they are willing to confer a favour
upon those who are journeying through much tribulation
ORSAN HYDE.
Note 1: Elder Hyde (Orson, not "Orsan") was an eye witness to
much of the conflict he relates in his letter -- however, later reports provided differing accounts of what actually
happened among the Mormons and the Missourians. The Rev. Isaac McCoy and the Rev. Benton Pixley both paint word
pictures of the situation, somewhat at odds with Elder Hyde's telling of the story.
Note 2: The Philadelphia Saturday Courier, of mid April, 1833 contained yet another of these eye witness
accounts from Western Missouri. See its reprint in the Apr. 20, 1833 issue of the Lebanon Ohio Eagle.
THE MORMONS AND ANTI-MORMONS. --
Our intelligence from the West by the mails, is not so late as that brought by the steam boat Charleston. The following
account is extracted principally from the Fayette Monitor:
Houses and property were destroyed, and the Elders of the Church severely
whipped by the mob, under cover of the night. It is impossible to forsee what
is to be the result of this singular and outrageous violation of the laws. We
fear that the party opposed to the Mormons will think themselves placed so
far beyind the pale of the law as to continue utterly regardless of it, and
eventually, by the power of numbers, be enabled to cut off the offending
sect. The loss of their relatives and partizans will stimulate them to these
acts, and fearful acts of bloodshed may have already been witnessed. As yet,
our intelligence is not very accurate, or full, in regard to the measures
taken by the officers of the county to surpass the rebellion as it may
properly be called. The entire county is probably arrayed on one side or on
the other; and in this state of things the power if the sheriff, and other
officers, to suppress the riot, is perfectly futile. It is reported besides,
that the Judge of the circuit, who attempted to interfer to stop the
proceedings, as well as some of the officers, were captured by the mob, and placed
in durance, either in jail, or in charge of some of their number, for a good
many hours; and the Lieut. Governor, who resided in that county, was driven
from it. In this state of things, we appregend the proper course would have
been for the authorities to have represented the case to the Executive, for
his interposition; but we have not learned whether they have done so. The
facts are, nevertheless, notorious; and the Governor should, without delay,
if he has not already done it, act upon them. He is bound to see that the
laws are executed against all offenders. The power of the county not
being available in this case, for almost all are concerned in the
insurrection -- the Governor should issue his Proclamation, calling out the
Militia of the neighboring counties, to enforce the laws, and to quell the
riot. He should give the requisite orders to the officers for that purpose;
and do it with all alacrity. It is very evident, that unless some effective
measures are adopted by him in this emergency, the lives of many valuable
citizens will be sacrificed, and the State suffer an irretrievable injury. A
rancorous deadly hostility, has long existed between the parties, and unless
the firmness and prudence of the Governor should be equal to the crisis, and
the offending party be severely punished, we must expect to hear of the
continual recurrence of such disgraceful proceedings.
We have nothing to do with the original causes of the quarrel. There may be
many worthless and intolerable members of the obnoxious sect; but the laws
are equal to the punishment of all those who are guilty of violating them. It
does not appear that they were appealed to at all prior to this contest. The
Mormons are as much protected in their religion, their property, and persons,
as any other denomination or class of men. We think that they acted perfectly
right in offering the resistance which they did, and thus far they have the
sympathy of this part of the community.
Note: Unfortunately, the extant 1833 files of the Fayette Western Monitor
do not appear to include the Nov. 8th issue from which the Republican
journalist drew much of his information for the above article. A paraphrase
of a Western Monitor article for Nov. 22, 1833 gives some of
the flavor of that paper's reporting of the Mormon situation in western Missouri, however.
DISTURBANCES IN JACKSON COUNTY. -- We are glad to receive more pacific accounts from the county of Jackson, in which such disgraceful broils
have recently taken place. We understand that the Mormonites have determined
not to oppose any further armed resistance to the wishes of the dominent
party, and that they were rapidly leaving the county and their homes, with
intention of forming another community elsewhere. They are determined
however, it is said, to prosecute the citizens engaged in hostilities towards
them, and for the depredations committed upon their property; and, in this
event, those who have disregarded all law may be made to feel its heaviest
penalties, both in their persons and fortunes. The Mormonites have
undoubtedly adopted the best course which was left to them; and all alarm has
subsided in that county.
All our accounts, we are happy to say, concur in one thing, that the original
statement as to the number killed, was much exaggerated. The most authentic
and latest accounts which has reached us, puts down the number at six --
two of the citizens, and four of the Mormonites -- and a good many wounded.
This statement was brought by the Steamboat Dove, from Independence, the seat
of justice of Jackson coounty. Many reports prevailed even in that quarter as
to the extent of the loss of life; and the first rumors may have well gained
circulation without any sinister motives in those who gave credence and
publicity to them.
We are informed, that an authentic statement of all the occurrences which
have disgraced that county, may be shortly expected. It was to be made out by
some very respectable gentlemen of the county -- who have, from beginning to
end, taken no part in the contest -- and in whose veracity every confidence
may be placed. Such a statement is due to the people of Missouri, whose
reputation must suffer in the eyes of all good men; and may remove much of
the odium which at present attaches to one of the parties engaged in this
disreputable contest.
Sirs. --
The object of this communication is to correct some erroneous publications in relation to
myself, which I discover are taking the rounds in the public papers, and also
to correct other statements in relation to the recent difficulties which have
occurred in this county, between the Mormons and their opponents.
It is well known, that I did not, nor could not approbate the proceedings of
that portion of the citizens of this county who have been engaged against
this sect of people; and that, in consequence of my forbearing to participate
in their measures, my situation has been vewry unpleasant. I have observed in
your paper a statement that the Lieutenant Governor was driven from this
county. This statement is entirely untrue. No violence has ever been done me
in any respect. I have also understood that a report has by some means got in
circulation, that I had assumed the authority to order out the militia, and
that I was compelled to do so by the populace: -- this statement is also
without the least foundation in truth. I have observed a statement in the St.
Louis Times, which is taken from your paper, above the signature of
"Orsan Hyde," in which Mr. Hyde states, that the militia were
called out on Monday the 14th instant, and that they participated in the
battle which was fought that evening near the boundary line. This statement
of Mr. Hyde is absolutely and entirely false. The information of that battle
having taken place produced the call of the Militia. The battle took place
about ten miles above this place, late on Monday evening, and the Militia
were not paraded until ten o'clock, A. M. on the next day (Tuesday.) The
Militia were ordered into service by Lieut. Colonel Pitcher, (the Colonel
being [called for] the purpose of suppressing the insurrection.) I approved
of the course adopted by Col. Pitcher, as the only means of saving bloodshed,
and of restoring order. On Tuesday morning, before the whole of the Militia
that were ordered out had assembled (about one hundred men had paraded,) a
messenger arrived in great haste, giving the information that the Mormons,
numbering perhaps one hundred and fifty, well armed, were then within a mile,
or a mile and a half of town, coming on with a view to attack and destroy the
place. -- Col. Pitcher thought it advisable to march his men to the western
edge of our town, and there to await the arrival of the Mormons, and, if
possible, to prevent bloodshed, and get those deluded people to disperse and
return to their homes. On reaching the western edge of the town, the Col. despatched one of the Mormons, as a
messenger to that portion of his brethren then in
arms, with this information, that the Militia were raised to quell this
insurrection, and that they must come forward, surrender their arms, and
return to their homes. This, after considerable consultation back and forth,
the Mormons at length complied with. They surrendered their arms and returned
to their homes, with the exception of three, who were delivered over to the
civil authority as having been engaged on the preceding day in the foregoing
battle over Blue. These three were subsequently discharged and returned to
their homes. The statement of Mr. Hyde, that the Militia acted as a mob, is
altogether false -- no men ever behaved better, nor was any person whatever
molested or injured by the Militia. Immediately after the surrender, the
Militia returned to town and were dismissed, with the exception of a small
guard intended to guard the Mormons. On the next day, or the day afterwards,
the Mormons took fright at the threats of the populace, and fled in every
direction. Mr. Hyde also states that Mr. Hicks was killed. This is a mistake:
Mr. Hicks was not within fifty miles of the place of action; he was in Lafayette County, attending the Circuit
Court. It is true, that the dwellings of the
Mormons were, to the number perhaps, which Mr. Hyde mentions, torn down by
the populace, under cover of the night. The persons engaged in this matter
are not known. The information which reached here about 8 o'clock on Monday
night, the 4th instant, by an express, giving intelligence of the aforesaid
battle, stated that the Mormons, to the number perhaps of sixty, well armed,
attacked a party of the citizens, numbering about 20; that he left them fighting,
and bore off the body of a small boy, who was shot in the back; that he could
not tell the extent of the bloodshed that had taken place. It has turned out,
however, that two of the citizens were killed on the ground, and several
wounded: the Mormons lost one man killed and several wounded. As it regards
the particulars of this aforesaid battle (and which is the only one that has
taken place,) I have taken measures to procure a correct statement; as soon
as it is obtained, it will be laid before the public. I have written to the
Governor, and have given him a statement in detail of such matters, connected
with this unfortunate occurence, as came under my observation; which he may
probably make public. You will oblige me and subserve the cause of truth, by
publishing this statement in your paper.
Gentlemen. --
I have resided about a year and a half within the Mormon settlements in this country. I have had
many of them employed at divers times to labor for us. I have said little to
them upon the subject of their peculiar notions of things, temporal and
spiritual and I have scarcely if ever mentioned even their names to one of my
correspondents. I should perhaps, remain silent upon this subject, had I not
been requested to make some statements of the facts which have occurred in
the late disturbances with the Mormons, and that this request had emanated
from a source which gives it a claim to a respectful notice.
An impression seems to prevail abroad that the Mormons are here persecuted on
account of their peculiar notions of religion. This, I think, is entirely a
mistake.
In the efforts that have been made to induce them to leave this county, many
have called them fools and fanatics, but I never heard that they had been
once interrupted in the performance of their religious services, nor that the
slightest injury had been done to either their persons or property on account
of their religious opinions and practices.
The Mormons, as I suppose from information, came here so ignorant of laws,
regulating intercourse with the Indian tribes, that they expected to pass on
into the Indian Territiry, procure lands of the Indians, aid them in adopting
habits of civilization, and attach them to their party. At the western line
of Missouri, they were arrested by the proper authorities of government.
Frustrated in this design, they located in this county, and procured land, to
a small amount only, for so great a number of persons. The village of Independence was by them termed
"Zion" in their public prints, and that
was the Nucleus of the New Jerusalem. They have repeated, perhaps, hundreds
of times, that this country was theirs, the Almighty had given it to them,
and that they would assuredly have entire possession of it in a few years.
Reports believed by many to be true, for the correctness of which I cannot
vouch, says that they repeatedly declared that if the Almighty should not
give it to them by any other miracle, it would be done by their sword -- by
blood, &c. However erroneous these reports might have been, such sayings,
appeared to the people very near akin to so many remarks which were common
among them, and unfortunately for the Mormons, these reports were believed to
be true, and the effect upon the public mind was accordingly.
By the steam boat Yellow Stone, the cholera was brought into our neighborhood
the past summer. It occasioned alarm but did not spread among the
inhabitants. On this occasion, one of them, an intimate acquaintance of mine,
appeared to be elated with hopes, that the accomplishment, of their
predictions was now at hand; that this plague was for the destruction of the
wicked, whilst they, the righteous, would escape. The intimations of a
similar feeling on the part of many others were too obvious to pass
unnoticed.
But the other citizens thought they discovered that the Mormons needed
neither pestilence nor sword to accomplish their purpose of getting entire
possession of the country. They were introducing a state of society which
would evidently become intolerable to others and would rid the country of all
who did not belong to their party.
A few of them are men of education sufficient for the transaction of the
ordinary business of the country; the principal portion of them are
illiterate, uninformed and superstitious. Some of them were suspected to
possess malicious and dishonest dispositions while others appeared to have
been gathered from among the shiftless and ignorant more or less of whom are
to be found in all countries, who live, as the saying is, from hand to mouth,
and whose condition in life could hardly be made worse. Such as have arrived
here fancied that they were within the rudiments of an imense city; preachers
were in various parts of the United States, portraying to this class of
people the glories of their "Zion," and exhorting converts to go up
thereto, and emigrants came in rapidly. The citizens became confirmed in the
belief that, among others they designed to influence such free blacks as had
been proselyted to their faith, and whose condition might be such that they
would not be prohibited by the laws of Missouri.
They were filling this new country with a people among whom others could not
live. In this Mormons gloried, and on account of it others grumbled. The
emigration to this country of others than Mormons, decreased, while those who
were here apprehended approaching necessity of removing from society in which
their children ought to be brought up and in which they could not be suitably
educated. Some had considerable possessions, if they should be compelled to
leave the Mormons alone would be the purchasers of their property, and
consequently at their own price, as they often boasted, would be the case.
Matters had not yet reached this state of things but were rapidly approaching
it.
Hitherto, the Mormons had been quiet upon the subject of politics, but it was
easily perceived that as matters were progressing, at no distant day they
would control all county business. It is reasonable to suppose that this
consideration operated to widen the breach between them and their opponents.
Under such inducements as these, a meeting of the citizens was called in Independence, to consult on measures
to prevent the maturity of the evils of which the
people complained. About this time threats were occasionlly made to throw
down houses, &c., their printing office, and their store house in
Independence were considered most in danger, but the Mormons were not much
intimidated; their store they said was the Lord's store-house, and therefore
it could not be injured, and if any one should extend his hand to injure the
house in which their Revelations, &c. were printed, his hand would
immediately wither.
Many of the more reputable citizens took part in this meeting; ardent spirits
were forbidden to the company, and the subjects introduced for consideration
were dispassionately discussed. They then proceeded to the Printing Office,
and razed it to its foundation to the apparent astonishment of many of them who
were looking on at a distance, and they put tar and feathers upon two of
their leaders.
A second meeting was held, and a compromise made. The Mormons by a committee,
agreed to leave the county, part of them by the 1st of January 1834, and the
residue by a given time next spring. Some of them were to remain unmolested,
and attend to winding up the business of the society; the damage done to the
Mormons' property was to be assessed by disinterested persons, and paid by
those who had injured it.
For some weeks the conduct and conversation of the Mormons indicated an
intention to comply with the terms of the compromise. But again they became
silent upon the subject of removal, and as formerly. appeared to be preparing
fields with a view of remaining. Not feeling themselves bound by bonds
subscribed by them under their peculiar circumstances, they instituted a law
suit for damages which had been done their property, and that suit is yet
pending.
While the other citizens little apprehended it, the Mormons procured powder
and lead and distributed it among them and also guns. In October,
threatenings to throw down houses, to whip their leaders, and to apply tar
and feathers increased. The Mormons bid defiance with increasing confidence,
and threatened retaliation by shooting. About the last of October matters
upon both sides grew more and more alarming every moment. About this time
they became strongly suspected of secretly tampering with the neighboring
Indians, to induce them to aid in the event of open hostility; for myself, I
could not resist the belief that they had sought aid from the Indians though
I have not ascertained that legal evidence of the fact could be obtained.
It has been stated to me that on Thursday the 31st October, a conspiracy was
formed by several Mormons to kill one of the citizens, and that on the night
of the following day a party actually approached the dwelling of their
victim, who fortunately was absent.
On the night of the 31st, a party threw off roofs, and otherwise damaged some
ten or a dozen Mormon cabins, on the West of Blue River; a Mormon leader
presented his gun in defence of either himself or property, he was warned of
the dreadful consequences which would follow his shooting, and he forbore; he
was taken and flogged; two other leaders were treated in the same manner.
On the night of Nov. 1st, Mormon houses in Independence were assailed with
bricks, doors and windows were broken, &c.
This party had scarcely completed their designs for that time, when a
considerable company of Mormons, armed, entered and for a while patrolled the
village.
On the same night a company of armed Mormons, under command of a leader, with
a sword by his side, hailed two men as they were passing the road upon lawful
business and ordered them to advance and give the countersign. On enquiring
for the authority of the party to detain them, one of them was told that he
was a dishonest man, upon which he struck the Mormon captain with his gun;
the captain then ordered the men to "fire." The party raised their
guns a little, but hesitated; another voice cried out "why don't you
shoot." They still disobeyed, but they seized the two men and put them
in what the party termed their "guard house," and gurded them till
morning, when they were let go without injury.
On the night of the 2nd Nov. a company approached a house, about five miles
west of Independence, with a view no doubt of injuring it, and as they
approached the Mormons fired on them and wounded a young man severely, though
not mortally. The party returned the fire without injury to any; the Mormons
fled; the party caught one of them and whipped him; but, as I understood, did
no further damage.
On the 3d, both parties appeared to be preparing for battle. Notwithstanding
a large majority of the citizens within the Mormon settlement desired to be
rid of them, there were many who had not countenanced the demolishing of
houses, &c. Some of these now felt it to be their duty to endeavour to
prevent the further shedding of blood. They therefore used entreaties and
offered to mediate between the parties, and to bear messages of peace from
one to the other, if it should be desired. One of my neighbors, who was thus
entreating with an active Mormon, was answered that they, the Mormons, had
resolved to fight while one of them remained alive. My neighbor then appealed
to his professions of religion, and reminded him that the Bible forbade such
a course as he said they had resolved upon. The Mormon replied that the
Israelites had been authorized by the Bible to drive out the Canaanites, and
he pleaded a similar privilege for his society.
A place of rendezvous on the 4th Nov. had been appointed by the citizens six
miles West of Independence. I supposed that the object of this meeting was to
agree upon further measures. In a consultation early in the morning with one
of my neighbors, we concluded that the method most likely to suceed in
allaying violent feelings on both sides, and thus preventing the effusion of
blood, would be to persuade them to have immediate recourse to the law. I
communicated this proposed expedient to an influential neighbor, who
accompanied me to the place of rendezvous for the purpose of applying it. The
matter was explained to a few gentlemen who had influence with the company,
who falling in with the plan, encouraged forbearance on the part of the
company.
It was pretty late in the day when I left the company; I then distinctly
understood that it had been agreed upon by them, not to interrupt either the
persons or the property of the Mormons, on that day, or the following night.
They agreed to meet again for consultation on the following day, by which
time such as were striving to make peace hoped that prosecutions would be so
far in progress as to satisfy all to resign their quarrel to the decisions of
the court. From this company I went in quest of Mormons; I found only three
or four, those I warned of the imminent danger I feared they were in, and
entreated them not to use their arms; that they could not possibly repel the
superior numbers which would appear against them. I advised that such of them
as desired to remain peaceable, would allow me to carry a message to the
other party in their behalf, and I persuaded myself that in that way they
would be allowed to remain unmolested. I also stated the conclusions on that
day, of the party opposed to them, and my hopes that if the Mormons could be
induced to manifest a pacific spirit, the whole difficulty might be disposed
of without the further shedding of blood. As the more influential Mormons
were embodied, I know not where, I could not get access to them. I therefore
desired, that intelligence should be given to them, that they all might
understand my desire to mediate, and might hear my advice. Unfortunately, the
suspicions of the Mormons that I was insincere, rendered these entreaties
unavailing; they now came rather too late. I was engaged in these
transactions when I was told that the reports of guns had been heard in a
direction which a company of Mormons had gone a few hours before, and that a
skirmish had likely occured.
After I had left the party, as stated above, and as they were about
dispersing . two lads arrived with intelligence that they had been a while
detained by the Mormons on the road, that they were armed, and said that none
should pass upon the road, &c. The party mounted their horses, and with
disorder equal to the rapidity, hastened to the place. A few Mormons were
seen, who fled; they took one and compelled him to promise not to take up
arms again, and dismissed him without injury.
The party returned to one of the Mormon houses; several women were seen
[hastening] away; they were told by many of the party that they need
apprehend no danger from them; [they], the company, agreed to disperse, and
[severally?] left for their homes in diverse directions, [some] fifteen or
twenty perhaps, loitered a little, [then] suddenly they were attacked on two
sides [by] the Moemons, the number of whom is [reported] to have been over
40. The Mormons [took?] possession of the ground on their side; six [there]
were wounded, one of whom died on the following day. Two of the other party
were killed upon the ground, but who did not belong to either party, another
who was there at the [time] was taken prisoner by the Mormons, and [detained?]
until the following morning, when he [was] let go without injury.
[It] is stated that on the night after the skirmish, several Mormons resolved
upon the death [of three] citizens, whom they particularly [se------ed] as
persons whom they supposed exerted [hostile?] influence against them
On the same night a party of Mormons, well armed, and apparently not wanting
in courage, left the Western Mormon settlement with the design of uniting
with others in an attack upon Independence.
On the following morning my anxieties and those of other peaceable persons in
the neighborhood, became very great. I was informed, in a way that I was
compelled to believe it to be true, that immediately after the battle of the
preceding day, Mormons in their mode of expression, had received a command to
"rise," and pursue their enemies and kill them whenever they found
them. Two Mormons came to my house early, one to ask advice what he should
do, the other to entreat me to use my influence with their opposers to
forbear the perpetration of cruelties upon them. I informed him that I was
then setting out upon that errand, and that through the course of the day I
proposed to return and visit the Mormons upon the same business of peace. I
then ascertained that the greater part of the Mormons could not be seen by
me, and justly conjectured that they were about to make a dreadful blow, and
that they would most likely strike on Independence.
It was early on the day of the 5th, that about 150 Mormons, apparently well
organized for battle, approached within a mile of Independence. At that time
there were perhaps not more than fifty guns in the Village; during the night
some of the Militia had been ordered into service. These were coming together
constantly, and it is probable that this apparent accumulation of men in
arms, was the occasion of a halt of the Mormons for a short time, when they
left the public road and turned into a suitable place for defence in the
woods. A message of peace was sent to them, and negitiations commenced which
did not terminate before three or four o'clock in the afternoon. In the
meantime the number of the Militia had so increased as to be about equal to
that of the Mormons. The latter surrendered fifty-three guns, the residue it
is supposed they conveyed away during the negotiations.
Had they reached Independence an hour sooner, it must in all human
probability, have fallen into their hands; and had they marched straight
forward into the village as they approached it, without hesitation, I think
they would have succeeded in taking it. It is probable that they designed to
kill or drive out all the inhabitants, and to destroy the Village. --
Had they succeeded in their design against Independence all the settlements,
extending 14 miles Westward would have been placed at their mercy.
Intelligence could not have reached the citizens in time for them to have
assembled [men] for resistance, and they could have saved themselves in no
other way than by flight. Here I must be allowed to exclaim, what an awful catastrophe
have we escaped! and how signal, and how merciful was that providence [which]
terminated the alarming doings of this day without the shedding of Blood!
On the following day, Nov. 6th, on my way to Independence, I met a company
who urged the necessity of taking possession of such arms [as] they were
still in possession of, fearing that [in] the present state of feeling, rash
measures would be resorted to. I entreated them to await my return when I
would [accompany them], to which request I understood them to agree.
A few miles further I met a much larger company going upon the same business.
I had too much reason to [believe] that lives would be lost upon that
enterprise, unless [something] could be thrown into the scale to balance the
[----] excitement which the friends of the deceased and [some?] others
labored under. I therefore proposed to [go] back with them; a few of the more
dispassionate [desired] me to do so, whilst others requested me to proceed
[to the] village and not to accompany them. I addressed a few respectful
remarks to them, and was permitted [to go] with them. I embraced every
opportunity of [endeavoring] to allay the excitement of individuals. The
company consented to appoint a leader. This gentleman conducted with much propriety
thro' the day. He [allowed?] me to propose to the company, that two or three
[persons?] only should approach a house in advance of the company, and inform
the Mormons that the object of the [men] was not to injure them, but merely
to request them to deliver up their guns. The plan was unanimously
[accepted], and with a few exceptions, it was adhered to [throughout] the
day. They allowed me to be one of [those] to go in advance under these
arrangements. The company proceeded until near sundown, when we [severally?]
returned to our places; no act of violence was committed upon any person, and
no depredation was made [on] any species of their property by this company.
[On] four days following, that is, on the morning of the [10th], a few of the
Militia were patrolling the settlements [forwards?] to the Mormons to defend
them against [m----- rash] men, and also to quiet the fears of the citizens.
{On] the 11th there was a meeting of a few citizens, [and] measures were
adopted for lessening the inconveniences of those who were leaving the
settlement. A [message] was sent to their leaders, that they would not [be]
molested in attending to the disposal of their lands or [their] property;
that it was only necessary that the names [of] such as they desired to remain
upon this business [should?] be made known, and excepting such as had
[become] too obnoxious to the citizens, they would be [com---ed] to the
friendship of all. In this way they might [avail?] themselves of the means of
aleviating their suffering, in a precipitate removal and much property would
[be] sold immediately for its full value. Very few of them [were?] at this
time in the neighborhood, though I have [no------] heard that they have
disposed of any of their lands. Among the many reports which have been
afloat, it [has] been somewhat difficult to come at that which was [correct].
In making out the foregoing statement, I have been influenced by such
information as I supposed was correct; [but] it is possible, that in the
details, my information in some small matters may have been mistaken, and
this is [the] more likely as I have had less opportunity of obtaining
information from the Mormons than from their opposers.
The telling of the foregoing tale has been a painful task, one which I could
not have performed upon any other considerations than a sense of duty to the
public, which [has] been urged by your request; hence you will please to
[---st], the high considerations of your obedient servant.
ISAAC MCCOY.
Note: This statement by the Rev. Isaac McCoy was written to the editors
of the Fayette Western Monitor and published in that paper about Dec. 6th. The letter was subsequently reprinted
both by the Republican and (in abbreviated form, a day later) by the Columbia Missouri Intelligencer.
Mormon leaders were quick to deny that Rev. McCoy had played "the part of a peacemaker" in during the conflict
between the Saints and their Gentile neighbors in and around Independence -- see the Republican's
article of Jan. 30, 1834. LDS historians like B. H. Roberts have generally
followed this early Mormon judgment and have accused the Baptist minister
(and famous missionary to the Indians) Isaac McCoy, along with other local
clergymen, of "leading armed bands of marauders" against the
Jackson County Mormons. According to Roberts, men like McCoy were "the
main inspirers of cowardly assaults on the defenseless." For a somewhat
more sympathetic view of the Rev. McCoy, his interactions with the Mormons,
and his Dec. 1833 statement, see Warren A. Jennings' "Isaac McCoy and
the Mormons," in the Oct. 1966 issue of Missouri Historical
Quarterly, (LXI:1, pp. 63-82). This piece reproduces lengthy quotes from
McCoy's 1833 journal, along with extracts from more of his obscure
holographs, not otherwise easily accessible for consultation.
THE MORMONS. --
The last Western mail brought us a handbill in defence of the motives and conduct of the Mormons since their settlement
in Jackson county in 1831. It is signed by three individuals of the sect -- Parley Pratt,
Newell Knight and John Carrill; and is dated on the 12th December. This
publication describes the persecutions which they have suffered, not to any
criminal violation of the laws or the rights of others, but to their
religious opinions. These persecutions are said to have been unrelenting, and
to have been accompanied by misrepresentation, and serious injury to property
and person. Of course, they differ from the opposite party in the details of
the disturbances of November last, which terminated in their expulsion from Jackson
county. The burden of the blame is thrown upon 'the mob,' as their opponents are
called: the writers accuse Lt. Gov. Boggs, Col. Pitcher, and Col. Lucas, of
practising a stratagem upon them, and thereby depriving them of their arms.
The conduct of the citizens, after the arms of the Mormons had been
surrendered, is represented in strong and indifnant terms -- bursting into
houses without fear, knowing the arms were secured, frightening the women and
children and warning them to flee immediately, or they would tear the house
down over their heads, and massacre them before night. -- They accuse the
Rev. Isaac McCoy, instead of acting the part of a peacemaker, (as he has
stated,) of appearing at the head of a company, with a gun on his shoulder,
ordering the Mormons to leave the county forthwith, and surrender what arms
they had; and 'other pretended preachers' are implicated by them in the
persecution. -- The writers continue the detail of the flight, subsequent
treatment and sufferings of their people, up to the time of publication. The
greater portion of them fled to Clay county, 'where the people are as kind
and accommodating as could reasonably be expected.' But a number of families
-- consisting of about 150 persons -- went into the new county of Van Buren;
from whence, the writers state, an express had just arrived, stating, that
these families were about to be driven from that county by force, after
building their houses and carting grain and provisions for 40 or 50 miles.
Several families had already fled. Van Buren county is estimated to contain
30 or 40 families, exclusive of their own sect. In a postcript the writers
state, that intelligence had been received from Independence, in Jackson county,
of fresh outrages having been committed near the village, on the night of
the 2d December, upon four aged and infirm families, who had been suffered to
remain there. The houses were injured and the lives of the inmates
endangered.
This is, perhaps, a sufficient notice of these unfortunate dissentions. Both
parties have a right to be heard, but at this time matters of more general
importance, claim precedence in our columns.
Charless &Pasehall.] St. Louis, Monday, June 2, 1834
[Vol. ? - No. ?
THE MORMONS. --
Difficulties are anticipated between the Mormons and the citizens of Jackson county. A letter from Independence, under
date of 21st May, says -- "The people here are in fearful expectation of a
return of the Mormons to their homes. They have heard that a reinforcement is
coming from Ohio, and that as soon as the Santa Fe company of traders leave,
the Mormons will re-cross the river from their temporary residence in Clay
county; in which event, much blood will be shed. It is not to be wondered at,
that they have chosen this as the 'promised land,' for it is decidedly the
richest in the state.' A merchant of Independence has, we understand, given
orders for a piece of artillery to be sent to him immediately, to be used in
defence of his property. The Mormonites are now on their way from Ohio."
Charless &Pasehall.] St. Louis, Monday,
June 30, 1834 [Vol. ? - No. ?
From
the Missouri Enquirer.
THE MORMONS
On Monday last, a
committee on the part of the citizens of Jackson county, and one in behalf of
the Mormon people, met in this place, to take into consideration the subject
of compromising the difficulties which occurred in Jackson county last fall.
At the suggestion of the Hon. Judge Ryland, the parties met at the court
house, and were addressed by him in an impressive and forcible manner,
relative to the importance and urgent necessity of bringing their
difficulties to an honorable adjustment. He portrayed to them, in lively
colors, the destructive and inevitable consequences which would result from
an onstinate refusal to bring this disagreeable and truly deplorable state of
things to an amicable end. He informed the commitees of the respective
parties, that it was not his province as a high judicial officer, to dictate
to them the terms upon which they should settle this subject; nevertheless,
as a man who felt deeply interested for his country and its laws, and the
happiness and well being of his fellow men, he advised them to ponder well
what they were about to do; and after enjoining upon them the necessity of
regarding the laws of the land, -- he addressed the Mormons, warning them
against the danger of suffering themselves to be led by pretenders to the
high preogatives of the Prophets of God, to certain destruction. With all the
candor of a man who felt the importance of the crisis, he informed them of
the real state of feeling that now pervades the greater part of the upper
country he supposed that the Mormons might cross the river and defeat the
citizens of Jackson in battle -- that it would only be the means of involving
them in greater difficulties -- that hundreds would rush from the adjoining
counties to revenge the blood of their neighbors, and that they must be
expelled in turn -- that the arm of the civil law could do nothing amid the
din of arms and the rage of war -- and he hoped they would reflect seriously,
before our rich soil should be deluged with the blood of our countrymen.
A meeting was then organized by the citizens of Clay county, for the purpose
of appointing a committee to act as mediators, and lend every possible aid to
effect a compromise, but without effecting any thing, the people became so
much excited, that it was thought most prudent to adjourn.
We are truly sorry to see such a state of things, yet it is a lamentable fact
that this matter is about to involve the whole upper country in civil war and
bloodshed. We cab not (if a compromise is not agreed to before Saturday next)
tell how long it will be before we shall have the painful task of recording
the awful realities of an extermination war. The crisis has arrived, and it
behooves every well-wisher of his country to act with prudence and self
possession, and to use every exertion to allay the impending storm.
We have very little idea that the Mormons will accede to the propositions
made by the citizens. We are told that such a hope is hardly entertained by
any of the Jackson committee, and we have no doubt but the citizens of Jackson are
determined to dispute every inch of ground. The chairman of the committee
declared in the court house, in the presence of five or eight hundred
persons, appealing to high heaven for the truth of his assertion, that they
would dispute every inch of ground, burn every blade of grass, and suffer
their bones to bleach on their hills, rather than the Mormons should return
to Jackson county.
(The paper also contains a correspondence between the commitees of the
respective parties, in which the people of Jackson county propose to buy the
possessions of the Mormons in that county, at an appraised valuation, with
the addition of 100 per cent. upon the ascertained value; or to dispose of
their property upon the same terms to the Mormons. The Mormon committee, not
being authorized to treat upon this subject, asked time to consult their
brethren.)
Charless & Pasehall.] St. Louis, Friday, July 25, 1834
[Vol. ? - No. ?
The health of St. Louis, notwithstanding the extreme heat of
the weather, is unusually good. The cholera was entirely disappeared.
The pestilence yet prevails at Chariton, among the Mormons, at Liberty, and perhaps other places on the
Missouri. Gilbert, a leader of the Mormons, died
from an attack of it, and Jo Smith, the Prophet, was on his way to Ohio, at the last account.
Some other deaths have occured at Rushville, Pekin, Dillon's Settlement, and
at Pleasant Grove, six miles above Peoria.